The polished teacher recipient receives a bottle of nail polish with the award. What do you think? I like it and I hope it goes over well!
Update!!!! Due to the overwhelming Pinterest response to this post I have added this to my Teachers Pay Teachers store. You can download it there for free at this link: Showing Appreciation! If you are not on TPT ( you should be!) you can download the file from google drive. If you can't access these please comment below with you email.